A middle-aged woman in the supermarket took two bags provided free of charge, the result was stopped by a supermarket security checks. The anger hearts and minds of women committed hypertension. Recently, it sued the supermarket compensation for their economic and spiritual losses. Municipality Nankai District People's Court after the view that different take on more and stealing two bags free nature of the defendant in the absence of express supermarket, requiring the plaintiff to check the behavior of all the goods purchased over when. So decree supermarket parent company to compensate the plaintiff for medical expenses and transportation costs 628 yuan. Supermarkets have to bear joint responsibility.
Controversial bags "free" understanding differences
Women Ryu alleged October 25, 2010 at 4 pm, and everybody likes her after three road Tianjin Shopping Plaza shopping checkout, walked away from the store entrance at about 5 meters with them, the two men were intercepted before asking She will pack the items out. Also ran four or five people, accusing the supermarket she stole items. After her alarm, the police rushed to the scene, she would pack a bag inside the chicken, a small ticket,http://bbs.liangtouniu.com/thread-622687-1-1.html, as well as supermarkets offer free two with two rows of small plastic bags pouring hole for inspection. After defendant scan confirmed ticket matter consistent and have payment. During her nearly two hours of personal freedom is restricted.
After the incident,http://bbs.yunos.com/read.php?spm=0.0.0.0.ox9hco&tid=263230795/read.php?tid=263230795&uid=1738509684&ds=1&toread=1, she experienced extreme physical discomfort, agreed to by the police, which went to the hospital. After being diagnosed with high blood pressure, doctors recommend vacation days. To resolve the matter,http://www.facetwitter.pw/?module=gbio9o3pcd6w, she went to the supermarket front desk, office or police station more than 20 times. However, the defendant does not resolve the matter in good faith. Therefore,http://www.xyxfw.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=237455&extra=, the prosecution asked the defendant compensation for medical expenses, lost income,http://wutuobang.net/apps.php?q=diary&a=detail&did=725234&uid=66151, and traveling expenses of the economic losses of more than 1590 yuan, 3000 yuan spirit of solatium.
Yue said the accused person, for the provision of free bags, Ryu had misunderstood. The defendant supermarket shoppers need only to provide packaging bags, packaging requirements can achieve, not randomly pick. Therefore, the defendant took the staff suspect Ryu supermarket stuff. Ryu staff found the defendant will not be free items into their bags, perform job duties through no fault. For this incident, the defendant's approach is correct, Liu claims no legal basis, it asked the court to dismiss all of the plaintiff Liu.
Court held that, when consumers buy goods or services,piumini moncler, the right to human dignity is respected. Plaintiff to the defendant to take on more purchases two free bags when in nature and theft of goods sold different. The use of bags at the mall should be expressed in advance in the form of notices. Security officers found the defendant took plaintiff more than just bags, tips back to the plaintiff. The requirement to check the behavior of the plaintiff purchased over when all the goods. And,http://www.cacenglish.com/index.php?item/create_form/1, when the plaintiff nor timely interception Liangmingshenfen. Therefore, the defendant bears the dispute occurred fault liability. In the course of time the plaintiff to resolve the dispute,http://aibeihaidao.net/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=291892, the economic losses due to physical discomfort caused by the defendant compensable. About spirit of solatium one, because the plaintiff claims that the lack of factual and legal basis, the court not support it.
Lawyers said to respect the human dignity of consumers
For this case, the city lawyer Yang Yi Qing? Said consumers when shopping, operators should ensure personal and property safety of consumers. More importantly, human dignity must be respected consumers.
Young? Suggestions, supermarket security personnel should distinguish between the boundaries of free articles theft and taken away,http://learningnetwork.childrensfoodtrust.org.uk/login/index.php?item/create_form/1, and the difference between the two types of behavioral treatment. Even some people exist theft, supermarkets should also promptly notify the police.
Hong Kong Daily News reporters Zhang Jiamin and Tong Xunyuan Southern France